Mature or past its prime? We are tasting a 2005 Spätburgunder.

The Schlossgut Diel 2005 Spätburgunder Cuvée Caroline has held up sensationally and is undoubtedly a great wine—one of Germany's top Spätburgunders. It offers notes of mocha, cherry, and herbs; it is full-bodied, dense, balanced, long, mineral-driven, complex, fresh, and highly drinkable. 19/20 points.